A settlement in William Thompson v. Todd Spitzer imposes guardrails on the Orange County District Attorney (OCDA)’s DNA collection program but the attorney who filed the lawsuit notes the agreement does not create an independent audit committee, implement automated compliance software, or mechanize punishment for non-compliance.
Instead, enforcement relies on court oversight if it’s believed the DA’s office is violating settlement terms.
“My understanding is that we can go back to court and request a hearing if we believe the DA’s office fails to comply with the agreement,” University of California at Irvine (UCI) criminology professor emeritus William C. Thompson said. “Abby Formella of O’Melveny & Myers, who helped represent me in this matter, investigated this aspect of the settlement.”
Known as Spit and Acquit, the “OCDNA” database was installed in 2007 by former District Attorney Tony Rackauckus.
Under the initiative, defendants accused of misdemeanor would either face charges, or alternatively, pay a fee to submit their DNA to a countywide database.
Thompson sued five years ago, alleging the database is a gateway to potentially unconstitutional arrests.

University of California at Irvine (UCI) criminology professor emeritus William C. Thompson
“A number of individuals have told me that they did not want to contribute DNA to the database but believed, based on the representations of a Deputy DA, that they had no other reasonable choice,” Thompson told OrangeCountyLawyers.com.
While the agreement has no direct binding authority in the state beyond Orange County, Thompson hopes the settlement will serve as a wake-up call for other California jurisdictions.
Signed on Sept. 24, the settlement agreement established safeguards like expungement after 15 years, and 30-day cooling-off periods for plea offers.
However, the settlement agreement does not require individual notification to those whose profiles are expunged.
“It is supposed to be automatic,” Thompson said. “The settlement agreement does require the DA’s office to report how many expungements have occurred, but that will only show the operation of the expungement operation in the aggregate.”
The 30-day cooling off period includes written disclosures and a chance to seek legal advice, which Thompson foresees will give people the opportunity to make a more thoughtful, informed choice about whether to accept the bargain the Deputy DA is offering.
“Our goal was not necessarily to change the rates of agreement, but rather to make the entire process fairer,” he said. “It is about ensuring that the choice to donate DNA is more knowing, intelligent and voluntary than it has been in the past.”
The OCDA did not respond to requests for comment by the time of publication.
Related Media:
The DNA collection program was considered unfair by critics prior to the settlement agreement because the biological data of suspects or accused people were permanently stored without a clear and available expungement path.
“Most people ‘age-out of crime by their late 20s,” Thompson said. “If someone has not committed another crime 10 years after their initial misdemeanor conviction, the chances they will start offending thereafter are nearly nil and that is particularly true for the kinds of violent and sexual crimes likely to be solved by DNA testing.”
As a result, Thompson believes that although the settlement agreement is a step in the right direction, it did not go as far as he would have liked.
For example, additional steps should be taken to reinforce the right to counsel for those charged with misdemeanors and the periods of time before expungement are too long.
“Our analysis suggests that a DNA database for misdemeanants may not be a cost-effective crime solving tool after all,” Thompson added. “There were many, many categories of misdemeanor offenses that never, ever, produced any ‘hits’ to crime scene samples, and certainly, never solved any crimes.”
Photo Credit: Photo of William Thompson provided by William Thompson, top header image created using ChatGPT.
Juliette Fairley covers legal topics for various publications including the Southern California Record, the Epoch Times and Pacer Monitor-News. Prior to discovering she had an ease and facility for law, Juliette lived in Orange County and Los Angeles where she pursued acting in television and film.